Bestway knitting booklet 78 |
One of the designs looked familiar, and checking through my small but growing pattern library I found that I already owned something very similar.
Spot the difference - the Bestway booklet is on the right |
In fact not just similar. The photograph is almost identical, apart from the fact that the Weldons pattern appears to have bands of plain colour where the Bestway pattern has a diamonds pattern.
My initial thought was that the Weldons version with the plain bands had been issued first, and then amended to include more Fair Isle details, to make it easier to knit with oddments. But the instructions are identical, apart from the fact that Weldons pattern uses W.B. Melody Knitting 3-ply, whereas Bestway uses Sirdar Super Shetland Wool 3-ply.
Bestway booklet on the left, Weldons leaflet on the right |
Looking closely at the Weldons image, I noticed that the knitting in the bands of plain colour isn't entirely smooth, and then it finally dawned on me - the band is knitted in two colours, but the difference is lost in black and white.
There is another photograph of the jumper on the back of the leaflet, which shows the design clearly. I wonder if this was down to different lighting, or if it was a version knitted in slightly different colours?
The design shows up clearly in this version |
The jumper is knitted with a white background, and uses yellow, green, red, brown, turquoise and saxe blue for the Fair Isle. I charted out the design.
![]() |
The two coloured bands have an identical pattern |
Obviously, I couldn't recreate the shades of wool used in the original, but removing the colour from the chart shows how similar some of the colours become.
![]() |
Now some of the colours are hard to tell apart |
Both the Weldons leaflet and the Bestway booklet were published by Amalgamated Press, who owned Bestway patterns.
![]() |
The small print - Weldons on top, Bestway below |
It seems safe to assume that this design was first released as a Weldons pattern, the problem with the cover photograph was noted, and when it came to be reissued by Bestway the negative was manipulated to add the missing design element. The work must have been tricky, but it was very well done.
Someone had to draw this in, stitch by stitch! |
I haven't been able to find out anything about the link between Weldons and Amalgamated Press. Before the war, Weldon's (with an apostrophe) used to publish its own magazines as well as knitting and sewing patterns. I’m guessing that either it was taken over by Amalgamated Press, or they had an arrangement whereby they shared some knitting patterns. Either way, I will be keeping an eye out for other replicated patterns in the future.