 |
| The dress for sale, and the original image from L'Officiel |
I still have all the images of the first dress stored away, so I thought that I would compare the two. (All images, apart from those of my own dress, are copyright Kerry Taylor.)
 |
| Front views |
From this, it's obvious that the dresses are very different shapes. The 2024 version is longer, and looks less full-skirted. The short, bell-shaped, skirt appears to have been a feature of Balmain's 1955 dresses, as it also appears on the 'Medallion' dress sold by Kerry Taylor in 2022.
 |
| Why yes, I 'would' like to recreate the Medallion dress one day! |
Of course this difference may just be because the client for whom it was made was a different shape from the owner of the 2015 version. However, the dress currently for sale has a narrower and deeper front neckline, and wider shoulder seams. The difference between the necklines is even more obvious at the back.
 |
| Back views |
The differences are explained in the condition report on the Kerry Taylor website, which states that the dress has been heavily altered. The report speculates that the upper part of the dress may have been damaged, and the lower section used to make a new dress. If so, it has been very skilfully done, given that the embroidered leaves on the bodice go over the princess seams, as on the 2015 version.
 |
| The princess seams on both are nigh-on invisible |
The embroidery is, rightly, described as "superb", but there is no doubt that it differs from the dress sold in 2015. This is perhaps best illustrated in the side view.
 |
| The side seam is more apparent |
Unsurprisingly, I have never bought a dress from a couture house - the nearest I have come to that is watching Mrs Harris Goes to Paris - so I have no idea how much the client can influence the overall look of their purchase. But there is no denying that the embroidery on the two versions is very different. The most obvious variation is in density. It's apparent in the two images above that the leaves on the 2015 version are far more tightly packed, with some overlaps, and the berries more bunched. Of course, the more widely spaced leaves of the 2024 version may be due to it being made from the lower section, where there are fewer leaves. Equally, some of the berries may have been snipped off and redistributed.
Another difference is that all of the leaves on the 2024 version are a broadly similar shape and all, with the exception of those around the neckline, point downwards. The dress sold in 2015 had a number of different leaf shapes, and they were orientated in different directions.
The actual design of the leaves is different, too. On the 2015 version, the central spine is indicated by a slight gap in the embroidery, whereas on the 2024 dress it is embroidered in silver thread. Also, all of the 2024 leaves are made with one side in a more blue-based palette and the other side more green and gold, whereas in 2015 there were some leaves entirely in the cooler shade, and less densely embroidered.
 |
| Close-ups of the embroidery |
I should add that none of this is in any way meant to denigrate the dress currently for sale, it's just that having spent far longer than is normal studying the dress sold in 2015, I was fascinated to explore the differences. The idea that there are different versions of the Holly dress out there pleases me immensely, as I feel that my version has elements of both of them.
 |
| My version - this remains my proudest sewing achievement |
 |
| And yes, I did base my jewellery choices on the L'Officiel image! |
Update, 10 December: Despite being unlabelled, heavily altered, and having an estimate of £200-£300, the dress sold for £2,400. Clearly I'm not the only one who loves the Holly dress!
No comments:
Post a Comment